The Rise and Fall of Hamilton
Nov 17, 2026 05:15PM ● By Seti Long, photos by Seti Long
Gridley Museum ambassador Pat Teague discusses the history of Hamilton, Butte County’s first county seat, during a presentation to the Gridley Rotary Club. Teague shared historical images and answered questions about the former Gold Rush community, where little remains beyond a small cemetery near the Feather River.
GRIDLEY, CA (MPG) - The rise and fall of Hamilton, once a bustling Gold Rush community and Butte County’s first county seat, was the subject of a recent presentation to the Gridley Rotary Club by Gridley Museum ambassador Pat Teague.
Teague has spent considerable time gathering information from the Butte County Historical Society and historical documents and articles archived about the town’s history.
Although the town existed for only a few years, its history is filled with Gold Rush fever, political maneuvering and potentially one of California’s earliest major land scams.
Hamilton was located along the Feather River, near what is now the Oroville Wildlife Area. On a good day, a few of the remaining headstones can be seen through the trees while driving north on Larkin Road near the Afterbay outlet.
Hamilton began attracting settlers after Gen. John Bidwell discovered small traces of gold in the area in 1848. By 1850, miners, merchants and entrepreneurs were arriving, hoping to make their fortunes.
The town’s founders had ambitious plans. Among them were Callen, Bristol, Stafford, Denton and London. They laid out streets, divided the land into lots and sold shares for $1,000, working toward what they envisioned as a $50,000 community. Ferry service to Marysville and then Sacramento was also part of the developing infrastructure, intended to lure more gold-hungry individuals from larger cities.
“The town was to be the gateway to the gold fields,” Teague said.
Businesses quickly followed, including general stores, saloons and boarding houses. Merchants made considerable profits selling goods to miners, with potatoes reportedly selling for as much as $60 a bushel and butcher knives for $30.
“Merchants supplied the miners, and they also made their fortunes. This practice has commonly been referred to as ‘mining the miners,’” Teague said.

A historical marker stands near the remains of Hamilton, Butte County’s first county seat from 1851 to 1853. Erected by Argonaut Parlor No. 5 of the Native Sons of the Golden West and the Butte County Board of Supervisors, the marker identifies the former townsite and notes that the courthouse stood 600 yards east of its location.
Hamilton’s promoters also worked to establish the town as Butte County’s first county seat. Following a disputed election in December 1850, Hamilton won with 484 votes, defeating Ophir City and Goodwell’s Bar.
A courthouse and jail were subsequently constructed, and by 1852, the community had approximately 200 residents and 35 buildings.
However, a land ownership scheme would ultimately lead to Hamilton’s downfall.
The founders believed the land was public domain and proceeded to sell town shares, including individual lots and entire blocks, to investors despite not officially owning the property.
“In other words, possession is 9-10ths of the law,” Teague said, describing the mindset of Hamilton’s founders.
People purchased property, built homes and opened businesses, believing they were making legitimate investments in a growing community. What they didn’t realize was that the land was part of the Fernandez land grant, which had not yet been legally transferred to those claiming ownership.
According to Teague, Gen. Robert V. Moore and his associate, James Henshaw, used a document announcing the purported purchase of the Fernandez grant to intimidate Hamilton’s residents.
“The paper suggested that the entire town of Hamilton and the county government, were squatters on private land, and that they would be ordered to leave,” Teague said.
The document served as an effective eviction threat, intimidating many of the settlers.
Frightened residents began selling their property and abandoning their investments. More than 200 people eventually left their homes and businesses behind. The courthouse, jail and other public buildings were abandoned, and by 1853, Hamilton was essentially a ghost town.
The most troubling part of the story was that the purchase was not legally completed until 1859, six years after Hamilton had ceased to exist.
Teague explained that the eviction threat was premature. Under emerging California law, residents potentially could have had another six years before facing eviction.
Today, little remains but a small, fenced cemetery with a handful of headstones and a historical marker identifying Hamilton as Butte County’s first county seat.
What began as a promising Gold Rush community became a cautionary tale of land speculation, intimidation and lost opportunity.

















