District Attorneys Challenge Newsom’s Clemency Order
Nov 17, 2026 04:26PM ● By MPG Staff
Logo courtesy of Butte County
OROVILLE, CA (MPG) - Butte County District Attorney Mike Ramsey has joined 28 other California district attorneys in a legal challenge to Gov. Gavin Newsom’s decision to commute 548 death sentences to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole.
Ramsey announced his participation Nov. 16 in a challenge filed with the California Supreme Court by the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation. The lawsuit contests the governor’s authority to issue blanket commutations without reviewing individual cases.
According to Ramsey, approximately 382 of the 548 inmates have multiple felony convictions, which require approval from a majority of the California Supreme Court before the governor can grant clemency under the state Constitution.
The legal challenge also has support from law enforcement organizations and victims’ rights groups, including the California District Attorneys Association, Peace Officers Research Association of California and Crime Victims United.
Ramsey criticized Newsom for issuing the commutations without consulting victims’ families or reviewing the circumstances of each case.
“Blanket commutations represent an abdication of the Governor’s responsibility to evaluate each case on its merits,” Ramsey said. “Each case leaves behind a victim’s family that has endured agonizing proceedings for years or decades, reliving the tragedies that befell their loved ones until they finally thought they had achieved some level of closure and finality.”
The challenge includes two Butte County death penalty cases involving Lee Max Barnett and Dannie Hillhouse, both of whom had prior felony convictions.
A jury sentenced Barnett to death in 1988 for the 1986 murder of Richard Eggett. According to the district attorney’s office, Barnett robbed and tortured Eggett near a mining camp before killing him. Barnett also had a criminal history involving robberies, assaults and rapes.
In the second case, a jury sentenced Hillhouse to death in 1993 for the 1991 murder of Brett Schultz. Prosecutors said Hillhouse robbed Schultz and stabbed him repeatedly after Schultz encountered Hillhouse and his brother in Chico.
Ramsey also questioned whether life sentences without the possibility of parole would permanently prevent convicted murderers from seeking release.
He cited the case of brothers Erik and Lyle Menendez, who received life sentences without parole in 1996 before changes in state law allowed them to seek parole.
“Contrary to the Governor’s assertion, life without the possibility of parole no longer guarantees that you will spend your life in prison,” Ramsey said.
Newsom imposed a moratorium on executions in California in 2019. Ramsey argues that the governor’s latest action goes beyond suspending executions by replacing death sentences without individual consideration.

















